The Evolution of God in the Mind of True Believers

Note:  the following progression is based on statements I have heard made by otherwise sensible people.  I feel strongly that human beings are inherently spiritual beings as well as physical beings.  We have an innate need for a connection with Deity.  The problem comes from the way we begin to “own” our beliefs and denigrate the beliefs of others.  It begins simply enough with the thought that “God is good.”  Totally harmless.  But then, the personal “ownership” of God takes hold and it becomes “my” God is good.  On and on the progression goes, and this God that once was just “good” and “love” becomes a demanding, punishing, hateful God who justifies the destruction of those who refuse to worship in a certain way.  Follow the sequence, and remember, I have in the past few years heard otherwise decent people say each of the things listed in this progression below that moves from a God of love to a God of hate.  This kind of progression can, and does take place in every faith tradition.  It is not something that can be attributed to just one faith.

The Evolution of God in the Mind of True Believers

God is good.  God is love.

Becomes….My God is good.  God loves me.

Becomes….My God is the God of all gods.  God loves me.

Becomes….My God is the real God.  Your god is false.  My God loves me.  My God loves you too, but not as much.

Becomes….It would be good if others worshiped my God because my God is real.  It would be easier to love everyone if everyone worshiped my God. Most of the problems in the world result from people not worshiping my God.

Becomes….It is important for me to convert others to the worship of my God because they will be lost if they continue to worship false gods.  My God loves me and punishes those who don’t agree with me.  All the problems in the world come from people who worship false gods.

Becomes….Everyone must come to worship my God because my God is the only real God.  God loves me and hates those who disagree.  It is my responsibility to make sure that people who worship false gods convert to worship my God.  If they don’t, the problems of the world will get worse and worse.

Becomes….It is urgent that those who worship false gods be converted, by any means necessary.  If they don’t convert they don’t deserve to live.  This world belongs to those who worship the one true God.  God loves me.  Anyone who disagrees deserves to die.

Becomes….Because there is only one true God (my God) there is only one true religion (my religion).  Anyone who deviates from the pure practice of the one true religion must be destroyed and all that they have done throughout history wiped out of the memory of those who keep the one true religion so they may remain pure (like me).

Becomes….God is good (like me and those like me).  God is love (for me and those like me).

Ultimately, of course, this is the idolatry of the self, and a total denial of Deity.

Posted in Personal Values, Spirituality | 2 Comments

Descended from heretics

Since childhood I have been attracted to the spiritual dimension of life, yet I seemed to have no choice but to question the dogmas and narrowness of so many aspects of organized religion.  In particular, I have never been able to limit the scope of Deity to just one set of religious teachings, to one little slice of “truth,” and more especially to just one religion.  Now in my retirement, I have been using some of my time to research my family genealogy.  Doing this seriously, insisting at every stage on having more than one primary document to verify information and not relying on stories or reports that cannot be verified has been a demanding and tedious process.  But it has been rewarding.

I have discovered, for instance, that I am descended from a long line of folk who took their faith very seriously, but who also resisted being forced into an orthodoxy that conflicted with their own understanding of spiritual truth.

For example, many of my colonial ancestors were Quakers who were among the first English settlers in Jamestown Colony.  They left England due to religious persecution and became successful farmers in Virginia.  However, from the beginning of the slave trade they not only resisted owning slaves, they actively opposed the practice, causing them great difficulty in their communities.

Some of my ancestors came to the New World from Germany, having migrated there from Switzerland where they were active leaders in the early Protestant movement.  They took their faith seriously and over several generations were forced to leave all they had behind to flee persecution.  Perhaps there is some genetic memory that has come down to me that has caused me since my teen years to strongly oppose any religious teaching that oppresses or condemns those who hold differing views.

One of my best known ancestors, my 11th Great Grandmother, was Anne Marbury Hutchinson.  Anne was born in Alford, Lincolnshire, England in 1591.  She was baptized at the parish church in Alford on July 20, 1591.  Her parents were Francis Marbury and Bridget Dryden.  She was 21 when she married William Hutchinson at St. Mary Woolnoth in London on August 9, 1612.  Anne was first a mother, giving birth to 15 children altogether, all but two of whom lived to adulthood.  She was also an intelligent and strong willed woman, attracted to the study of the Bible and of theology.  She and her husband were so enthralled with the Puritan preacher, John Cotton, they quickly followed him to the New World after he fled England due to persecution by the Anglican Church.  She arrived in Boston aboard the Griffin in 1634 at the age of 43.  While her husband’s business flourished and his civic roles increased, she began to teach Bible classes in her home, a situation quite unusual for a woman in those days.  Soon, the classes were filled with both men and women, some coming from distant towns and cities.  Because her views were generous to other people of faith (non-Puritans in other words), the Puritan leaders of the colony took offense.  Governor John Winthrop, in 1636, began to warn that her views were dangerous to the state, and she must stop her teachings.  Anne continued to teach and the crowds attending her classes only grew.  Finally, in 1637 a trial was held and she was convicted of heresy.  The court banished her from the Colony.  She was given three weeks to leave.  Because of this, Anne and William, along with a few others, used their wealth and experience to purchase land from the Indians and in 1638 they established a purely secular colony which eventually became Rhode Island.

I am proud to be descended from heretics like Anne.  I pray that I may continue in old age to question, doubt, and resist any effort by religious authorities to limit Deity and to condemn those whose spiritual experience is different from theirs.


Posted in General thoughts, Personal Values, Spirituality | 4 Comments

Scientific method and spiritual exploration

Science explores the physical universe, using a method of question and verify.  One may reasonably have doubts about specific scientific conclusions.  However, provided the scientific method is being followed fully, one may not reasonably question the overall process nor can one reasonably reject the theoretical basis for such scientific inquiry.  Those who reject science because its findings conflict with their religious beliefs are foolish.

On the other hand, those scientists who summarily reject spiritual conclusions because they cannot be “proved” via the scientific method are equally foolish.  This is a complex universe.  There are multiple dimensions and the physical dimension is just one of those.  There also is a spiritual dimension which, because it is not physical, cannot be identified, explored, or verified using the scientific methods of physical science.

Unfortunately, many if not most of those who claim to be “spiritual” are not.  And equally unfortunate, those who should be exploring the spiritual dimension, adding to our understanding and appreciation of this mysterious reality have failed in their duty.  Instead of questioning and investigating, they have dug in their heels and insisted on defending primitive spiritual teachings.  They quickly condemn anyone who dares to ask new questions or posit refinements on spiritual theory and understanding.

If physical scientists acted like their spiritual counterparts, we would still be defending the early scientific knowledge of the ancient Persians, Chinese, Egyptians, and Greeks.  We also would still be living in a pre-industrial age.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Tea Party Bullies

I am truthfully amazed at the cynicism and recklessness of Tea Party Republicans.  But then I remember that most of those in the Tea Party wing are also those who have consistently denied the reality of global warming and want “creationism” taught in place of science in our public schools.  Our constitution provides three branches of government, that working together, crafts laws that, as a whole, tend to benefit the general welfare of our land.  They must sooner or later accept that the legislative branch passed a law that their little group failed to block.  The executive branch upheld that law and continues to do so in a constitutional manner.  And the judicial branch found the law to be fully consistent with the constitution.  They lost their battle at all three levels.  So now, like bullies on the playground, having failed to get their way in a constitutional process, they have taken our entire nation hostage.  They are putting millions of their fellow Americans out of work, taking food out of the mouths of infants, shutting down Head Start, and generally putting our entire economy at risk simply for spite!  Are there any rational, constitution loving Republicans left who have the courage to stand up to these spiteful little bullies?  Where are they?

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

About Elephants and Truth

Before I retired, people who visited my office would often question me about the number of elephants I had around the room.  There were carved elephants of wood, stone, even solid coal.  There were crystal elephants from Denmark and brass elephants from India.  In addition to the elephant figures on my desk, bookshelves, and other places around the room, there also  were elephant paintings and photographs on the wall.  Some of my visitors asked if I were a Republican (certainly not!!!), or why I did not have “religious art” instead of these dozens and dozens of elephants.

Elephants have been my personal totem, if you will, for many years.  As a child I was fascinated by the size and grace of elephants.  Elephants are noted for their intelligence and loyalty, to family and to tribe.  They tend to live long and to maintain strong, positive relationships.  In some very ancient traditions, elephants symbolize the removal of obstacles and barriers.  There are a lot of reasons why one might select elephants as an object to collect.

For me, however, the elephant is not the object, however fascinating and wonderful it may be.  I collect elephants because of the nature of Truth which is illustrated in the ancient Hindu story about the blind men and the elephant.

You no doubt know this story.  It tells of several blind men who approached an elephant from various directions.  Each touched a different part of the animal and attempted to describe the “truth” of their discovery to the others.  One touched a leg, round and rough and tall like a tree.  Another touched the tail and, to him, the elephant was like a rope.  Still another touched the side of the elephant and insisted that the elephant was just like a stone wall.  As each man touched a different part, each described the animal differently.  Each told the truth.  Each experience of touching was valid.  Yet, none of them, because of their limitations, could experience the total truth of the elephant.

This story has great meaning for almost every situation, but especially for religion.  The “truth” of the Divine is so far beyond the limits of human experience and understanding, it cannot be known in its totality.  Each of us may have a religious experience or a spiritual insight that, for us and for that moment, is fully “true.”  But another person may have an experience or insight that, while is seems contradictory to ours, is equally “true.”  Gaining an understanding of “Truth and Elephants” is a first step toward leaning how to feel comfortable within one’s own religious context while being able to affirm and enjoy that of others who come at the Divine from different directions.  My truth and your truth are both true, just not the total truth.

Even the elephant itself cannot know the total truth of what an elephant is, because the elephant only understands the “truth” of being an elephant from the inside.  Of course, those who are not elephants can only understand the “truth” of being an elephant from outside, so they, too, only know part of the truth.

The next time someone tries to convince you they have “the Truth,” remember the elephant.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

My Thanksgiving Prayer for 2012

Let us give thanks, not only with our words, but also with our hearts and with our actions of generosity to our neighbors around us.

Let us be thankful for the sky, the seas, and the very earth.  It is here that we live and thrive.  Let us be thankful for those with whom we share this earth.  We are blessed by the diversity of people, traditions, cultures, and faiths that can so enrich our lives if we are open to all of the bounty that is before us.

Let us be thankful for the food that gives us energy and also pleasure.  We do not forget the labor of those who cultivated the fields, cared for the livestock, collected and transported, and finally prepared this food so we can enjoy it and benefit from it.  Nor do we fail to give thanks for the living creatures of the earth whose lives have been given as a sacrifice for our benefit.

As we gather with friends and family to give thanks for our many blessings, we remember that there are many in this world who have no abundance of food, or of shelter, or of loving community.  We seek divine strength and courage to work together for a world society that is more just, where hunger is not known and where those who suffer from disaster receive prompt and loving care.  May we learn to work together to build a global society that is filled with peace, freedom, an abundance of resources shared according to each person’s genuine needs.  May we come to know that the Divine Spirit that we each worship in different ways, is the same Spirit of love and of justice even when called by different names.

And so with great thanksgiving, we join together as one human family to share meals,  fellowship, and joyful time together.  May it be so, now and forever.

Posted in Personal Values, Spirituality

Voting Against the Principalities and Powers

So Billy Graham is urging voters to vote for candidates who support what he calls “Biblical values.” Of course, his list of Biblical values is quite limited, and he leaves out virtually all the ones emphasized by Jesus, such as:  caring for the poor, seeking justice for the oppressed, etc. His rather blatant endorsement of Mitt Romney extends to suddenly removing the long-standing condemnation of Mormonism from his website. How strange and pathetic. As for me, I’ll vote the values of Jesus, Moses, Buddha, Vivekananda, Mohammed, and Bahá’u’lláh this election.  That means that I will vote against the “principalities and powers” and so far as possible, for justice and mercy.

Posted in Personal Values, Politics | 4 Comments